Skip to content
Zaviye Strategic Studies Institute Zaviye Strategic Studies Institute

Limited Deterrence Under the Shadow of the Israeli Threat

To What Extent Does the Qatar–Turkey Defense Agreement Ensure the National Security of Both Countries?

15 November 2026 4 min read
The Qatar–Turkey defense agreement, against the backdrop of Israeli threats, has raised questions about the effectiveness of regional alliances: Is lasting peace possible without containing Israel and moving from imported security to endogenous security?
To What Extent Does the Qatar–Turkey Defense Agreement Ensure the National Security of Both Countries?

Zaviye Institute: The recent defence agreement between Qatar and Turkey, signed by officials from the two countries in Istanbul, is indicative of a reconfiguration of the security relations of West Asia and the Persian Gulf littoral, as well as regional countries’ efforts to reduce their vulnerability to growing threats. The agreement, which emphasises military cooperation, joint exercises, the development of defence industries and the adoption of a unified position in response to external attacks, was concluded at a time when the continuation of Israel’s military actions and the crises arising from them have highlighted the ineffectiveness of existing regional security mechanisms.

Against this backdrop, the fundamental question is to what extent such agreements can be effective in the face of real threats, and whether they are capable, in the absence of changes to the fundamental equations of regional security, of creating sustainable deterrence at all.

First, the Doha–Ankara agreement should be assessed within the framework of Qatar’s efforts to diversify its security guarantees and Turkey’s efforts to expand its strategic depth. Despite hosting Al Udeid Air Base and maintaining close relations with Washington, Qatar has realised that reliance on extra-regional powers does not necessarily mean immunity from threats. Turkey, for its part, is seeking to strengthen its position in the security arrangements of the Persian Gulf by drawing on its military capabilities and defence industries. Nevertheless, an increase in the number of military partners does not necessarily lead to a commensurate increase in security.

Read more: The Possibility of a Direct Iran–Turkey Confrontation: Examining Three Dangerous Scenarios for Escalation

Second, the most important limitation of this agreement concerns the nature of the threats affecting regional security. Israel’s military actions in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria, and the expansion of the scope of regional tensions, raise the question of whether bilateral defence pacts are fundamentally capable of containing an actor that pursues its security calculations independently of the concerns of many regional states.

Recent developments have shown that the mere existence of political and military alliances is no guarantee against the expansion of Israel’s operations, which are the region’s greatest driver of war, insecurity and instability. Accordingly, exaggerating the capacity of the Qatar–Turkey agreement to create deterrence against Israel, in the absence of practical mechanisms and shared political will, would not be realistic.

Third, the new agreement forms part of the emergence of a network of defence cooperation among Turkey, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and several other Islamic countries. Although this trend could help develop military capabilities and reduce dependence on arms imports, differences in the members’ strategic priorities, some countries’ reliance on the United States, and the absence of a shared understanding of the threats limit its effectiveness. Alliances that lack consensus on the source of threats and how to address them may, in times of crisis, become symbolic arrangements rather than instruments of collective action.

Fourth, the fundamental issue is the distinction between imported security and endogenous security. The experience of the past several decades has shown that the extensive presence of foreign forces and bases has failed to turn West Asia and the Persian Gulf littoral into a stable region. Sustainable security takes shape when the countries of the region, by accepting shared responsibility, establish mechanisms for dialogue, confidence-building, non-aggression and the resolution of disputes.

Read more: Yemen’s Trap for Ankara: Is Trump Drawing Turkey into a Costly War?

Within such a framework, defence cooperation between Qatar and Turkey will acquire greater strategic value only when it helps strengthen an inclusive regional security system, rather than leading to the reproduction of limited bloc formations and external dependencies.

Looking ahead, the Qatar–Turkey agreement will probably lead in the short term to increased military coordination, the expansion of arms cooperation and the strengthening of the two countries’ political positions; however, turning it into an effective factor for regional stability faces serious obstacles. Until the threat arising from the expansion of Israel’s military operations is contained, mechanisms for responding to violations of states’ sovereignty are strengthened, and the regional powers reach an understanding on the necessity of collective security, such agreements will have primarily precautionary and limited functions.

In the long term, two paths are conceivable: the continuation of fragmented alliance-building and the intensification of security competition, or movement towards an inclusive security architecture involving all the countries of the region, including Iran and the Arab countries. The second path requires moving beyond a bloc-oriented outlook, reducing security dependence on foreign powers, and developing shared political will to contain warmongering and respect states’ sovereignty.

Overall, the Qatar–Türkiye defense agreement should not be regarded as a decisive turning point in ensuring the security of West Asia. The agreement may strengthen the defensive capabilities of both parties, but it will not replace a fundamental resolution of the region’s crises. As long as threats arising from Israel’s military actions persist and regional countries continue to seek their security primarily through the support of foreign powers, bilateral pacts cannot guarantee lasting peace. The future of Middle Eastern security will depend less on the proliferation of defense agreements than on the emergence of an endogenous, inclusive security order based on the shared responsibility of the countries of the region.

How useful was this analysis?

Be the first to rate

Cite this analysis

Hamid Khosh-Ayand (November 2026). «To What Extent Does the Qatar–Turkey Defense Agreement Ensure the National Security of Both Countries?». Zaviye Strategic Studies Institute. https://zaviyeinsight.com/en/2026/11/15/qatar-turkey-defense-agreement-national-security/

Reader comments

Leave a comment

Comments are published after review. Your email will not be shown.